Hello dear
Welcome To The Old Mill Inn
At The Old Mill Inn, nestled in the charming Alfred Station, we invite you into a warm, welcoming atmosphere filled with delightful culinary offerings. Our story is one of passion and community, where local patrons and families come together to enjoy flavorful dishes, from hand-cut steaks to kid-friendly favorites like grilled cheese and chicken nuggets. We pride ourselves on our friendly service and a vibrant ambiance, complete with a game room that appeals to all ages. Guests rave about our famous wings and rotating specials, making every visit a memorable experience. Come, share in our journey—where good food and great company meet!
About
The Old Mill Inn
Welcome to The Old Mill Inn, a delightful dining destination nestled in the heart of Alfred Station, New York. Located at 1 Depot, this charming establishment has quickly become a go-to for locals and visitors alike, offering a unique blend of mouthwatering cuisine and a cozy atmosphere.
If you're searching for a place that embodies community spirit and delectable dishes, look no further than The Old Mill Inn. As you step inside, you'll be greeted by friendly staff ready to enhance your dining experience. Many patrons rave about the vibrant atmosphere, citing everything from delicious food to a diverse crowd that includes families, college students, and locals.
The menu at The Old Mill Inn is a treasure trove of culinary delights. For families dining with kids, the offerings such as Grilled Cheese, Mac 'n Cheese, and Chicken Nuggets come complete with a side of crispy french fries, a fried Oreo, and a refreshing drink—all for just $7.25! It’s a fun and flavorful way to keep the little ones happy.
One of the standout features of The Old Mill Inn is its daily specials, particularly the exquisite selection of hand-cut and marinated steaks that are flame-grilled to perfection. Be sure to ask your server for the chef's lunch and dinner highlights—they never disappoint.
When it comes to satisfying your sweet tooth, the desserts at The Old Mill Inn are truly irresistible. Indulge in Cannoli piped fresh to order, Fried Dough tossed in sugar, or the delightful Apple Pie Logs drenched in caramel sauce. Each dessert is a perfect finale to an enjoyable meal.
Customer reviews highlight the commitment to quality and service at The Old Mill Inn. For instance, Paul M. and Sean G. both praised the excellent wings and the engaging atmosphere, while Belinda T. enjoyed her drinks and the generous portions that made dining out a pleasurable experience. Marcie C. appreciated the beautiful setting, despite some thermal discomfort on a particularly hot day.
If you haven't yet discovered this hidden gem in Alfred Station, now is the perfect time to pay The Old Mill Inn a visit. With a rotating menu that caters to diverse tastes and an atmosphere that encourages relaxation and enjoyment, you’ll find yourself returning time and time again. As the saying goes, good food, great company—The Old Mill Inn has both in abundance!
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ My wife and I decided to try out the restaurant tonight because we had heard they had good wings. I was surprised how big and perfectly cooked they were, we split an order along with the grilled cheese sandwich platter. I can say we enjoyed everything very much along with the good service from the staff. Thank you for a enjoyable experience and we shall be back! ”
“ Im an Alfred local who hadn't been back in a while, and what an amazing direction this place has achieved. Great food, beer selection, and atmosphere. Saw locals, family's, and even college students there filling the restaurant up on a Tuesday night. Don't hesitate to stop at this hidden gem in Alfred Station! ”
“ We came never having heard of The Old Mill Inn but they were open on a Monday while so many other places weren't. My drinks were great, the service was wonderful and the food excellent. It's been a long time since we've gone out to eat and thoroughly enjoyed all of our meal and eaten everything. The serving sizes were perfect. We highly recommend a visit or several. We knew before we were even done eating, and told the staff, that we would be coming back. ”
“ 1st time visit. My only issue was hot EXTREMELY hot it was inside. It was a 90 day and it was MUCH cooler outside. It's a beautiful setting, but uncomfortable to enjoy. The game room was a big hit! ”
“ It’s been a few days since we’ve been to The Old Mill Inn, and I’m still thinking about the wings. They were excellent! The menu had a great variety of food and the restaurant itself has cool, what we call “I Spy” items on the wall and on shelves. There’s also a pool table and arcade upstairs. With Alfred State and University close by, The Old Mill Inn is definitely a great place to eat. ”
“ Extremely fun laid-back environment. We happen to be there on trivia night and it was a madhouse, but that did not affect the quality of food nor the quality of service . This will quickly become one of our new favorite places to come visit when we’re in New York . Thank you! Keep up the great work! ”
“ Been coming to Alfred for the past 2 years and this our first time coming here and wish we came sooner. We came on a Sunday around 130ish so the place was pretty empty but we still enjoyed the atmosphere. Pizza and wings were really good burger and fries were just ok but still looking forward to next time we come up here and trying this place out at night when I'm sure it gets really busy ”
“ Very clean facility with a rustic feel, amazing wine selection and full bar, great dinning areas upstairs and down. Fit for a date or the whole family. Definitely a must stop. ”